Tuesday, February 26, 2008

Department of Homeland Security Search and Seizure Policy--A Threat to Anthropologists?

On February 15, NPR's Morning Edition reported that two civil liberties groups—the Electronic Frontier Foundation and the Asian Law Caucus—are suing the Department of Homeland Security to force it to disclose its policy for searching US citizens and their electronic devices when re-entering the United States.

The NPR piece, “Suit Accuses Homeland Security of Illegal Searches” opens with the story of a naturalized US citizen who recently returned from a three-week trip to Jordan. According to the piece, customs agents demanded to know the names of everyone the woman met in Jordan and the addresses of all the places she visited. They confiscated her cell phone, and when it was returned, her record of recent calls had been erased.

Many anthropologists may not be aware of the rights of the government to copy all documents, including electronic documents, carried across the borders. As scholars and professionals who frequently conduct research outside the US, anthropologists may be placed in a difficult and potentially unethical position if required to reveal confidential information about their informants to US customs officials.

Share your thoughts. Have you ever been subject to search and seizure policies at US Customs? In light of Homeland Security policies, what precautions should anthropologists take to protect those whom they study? What actions, if any, should the AAA take to uphold its Code of Ethics?

Related Links

CNet News article

Boing Boing article - includes a pdf copy of the EFF complaint

AAA Code of Ethics

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

Perhaps - if you are taking good care of information gathered from people you care about - information should be properly secured from any prying eyes.

It's not the fault of 'customs officials' that you feel you are 'placed' in a 'difficult and potentially unethical position' - you've allowed yourself to be placed in a position which you feel uncomfortable about.

Presumably, other than the irritation caused to your publication plans, were you to accidentally lose your field notes (with, perhaps, information identifying your informants) you wouldn't be quite so concerned.

I'm not going to prescribe just how you'd protect information from real / perceived misuse - but there are technological and very mundane approaches that would work.

I do kind of think, too, that there is a large degree of paranoia and consipracy-thinking here where all customs officials are part of some massive and co-ordinated intelligence-gathering activity ...

Mils.

Anonymous said...

There are many reasons that your data should not be stored locally, even when you are not crossing national borders: security, privacy, IRB type prescriptions, possible hardware failure, etc.

This story suggests a further reason that we should all be very conscientious about remote back up of our documents and data.

Anonymous said...

payday loans toronto This website is the expert I appreciated it quite a bit
AAA Toronto Payday Loans 1172 Bay St #101, Toronto, ON M5S 2B4 (416) 477-2817

Anonymous said...

酒店經紀酒店打工 酒店工作酒店上班 酒店兼差 酒店兼職 打工兼差 打工兼職台北酒店 酒店應徵 禮服酒店 酒店經紀 打工兼差

onwebmedia said...

Personally, the post is in fact the most excellent on this impressive topic. I harmonize with your conclusions and will keenly look further to your future updates.
Richardson Home Alarms

cheap jerseys said...

Many anthropologists may not be aware of the rights of the government to copy all documents, including electronic documents, carried across the borders. As scholars and professionals who frequently conduct cheap nhl jerseysresearch outside the US, anthropologists may be placed in a difficult and potentially unethical position if required to reveal confidential information about their informants to US customs officials.

Unknown said...

Nice information, valuable and excellent design, as share good stuff with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information and inspiration, both of which I need, thanks to offer such a helpful information here.
-------------------
Report for College

Unknown said...

Thanks a lot for sharing this nice and informative post, This posts shows your efforts that how do you cover any topic research. I really like your blog because your blog has updated posts on different current issues. I would request you to keep sharing your thoughts.
------------------------------
uk writing